News Summary
A federal judge has granted legislative immunity to Warwick officials in a lawsuit claiming First Amendment violations by city council members during a public meeting. The lawsuit, filed by Rob Cote through the ACLU, alleges Cote was unlawfully removed when discussing city governance. While the case against the city continues, the judge emphasized accountability should come through elections, not lawsuits. The situation raises concerns about free speech in governmental settings, with significant implications for citizens’ rights.
Warwick, Rhode Island – A federal judge has ruled that Warwick officials are protected by legislative immunity in a lawsuit alleging violations of First Amendment rights. The ruling comes after the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Rhode Island filed the lawsuit on behalf of Rob Cote in August 2023. Cote claims he was unlawfully removed from a Warwick City Council meeting while attempting to speak during the public comment period.
The incident occurred when Cote was addressing the council, making comments pertaining to a news story about Councilwoman Donna Travis, who presided over the meeting. According to Cote, he was discussing topics related to city governance, but Travis interrupted him and ordered him to leave the meeting, stating he was not discussing city government matters. As a result of this directive, police subsequently escorted Cote out of the meeting.
In his lawsuit, Cote accuses members of the Warwick City Council of infringing upon his First Amendment rights, specifically his rights to free speech and to petition the government. Following the lawsuit’s filing, the city council members sought to dismiss the case. However, Senior U.S. District Court Judge William E. Smith ruled to dismiss the individual members of the council from the case in their personal capacities.
While the ruling allows for the case against the city to continue, Judge Smith emphasized that legislative immunity does not provide a blanket protection for constitutional rights violations. He highlighted that accountability for such actions should be resolved through electoral processes rather than through federal lawsuits. The judge raised questions regarding whether Travis’s actions constituted legitimate legislative activity, suggesting that local legislators possess “absolute immunity” only when undertaking officially sanctioned duties.
Councilwoman Travis, who has chosen not to run for reelection, is currently facing a misdemeanor charge related to the very issue Cote raised during the council meeting. This development adds further scrutiny to her actions during the public comment period.
Cote expressed concerns about the implications of the ruling, stating that it could undermine free speech rights across Rhode Island. He criticized the decision, suggesting it may enable public officials to silence speakers at public meetings without facing consequences.
Meanwhile, Steven Brown, executive director of the ACLU of Rhode Island, reaffirmed the organization’s commitment to the case against the city. He emphasized the importance of public participation in government and reiterated that the matter would continue to be pursued through the judicial process.
Marc DeSisto, the attorney representing Warwick and its city council members, chose not to provide comments regarding the ongoing case. In the wake of the ruling, the focus will remain on the legal proceedings involving the city, while the underlying issues surrounding free speech and governmental accountability continue to resonate within the community.
This case underscores the delicate balance between legislative immunity for public officials and the protection of citizens’ constitutional rights. As the case proceeds, it may have lasting implications for how public discourse is managed in governmental settings in Warwick and potentially beyond.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- Boston Globe: Judge Rules Warwick Officials Immunity in First Amendment Lawsuit
- Warwick Post: Council Backs RI Civil Rights Enforcement Bill
- WPRI: Consent Order Issued in 1st Amendment Fight with Warwick City Council
- GoLocalProv: RI Teacher Files Federal Lawsuit Alleging He Was Let Go for Refusing to Pay
- Wikipedia: First Amendment to the United States Constitution
