Rhode Island Struggles with Natural Gas Dependency

News Summary

Rhode Island is facing significant challenges in reducing its dependency on natural gas, with a committee deeming a transition to renewable natural gas (RNG) as unrealistic. Over half of the state’s households depend on natural gas, which contributes nearly 40% of emissions. Stakeholders are concerned about RNG’s viability and the need for alternative energy strategies to meet climate legislation goals. The committee is expected to provide recommendations to tackle these climate challenges while balancing economic implications for residents.

Rhode Island faces significant challenges in reducing its dependence on natural gas as a state committee has recently deemed a shift to renewable natural gas (RNG) unrealistic. This decision comes amid increasing pressure to address greenhouse gas emissions as mandated by the state’s climate legislation.

During a recent meeting, several members of the committee indicated their intent to exclude RNG and alternative fuels from the final emission reduction report. They argued that RNG is neither feasible nor financially viable at this time. Currently, over half of Rhode Island households rely on natural gas, and the state’s natural gas system, overseen by Rhode Island Energy, contributes almost 40% of the state’s total emissions.

RNG is produced from biomass or renewable resources through the decomposition of organic matter, such as animal waste or food waste. However, stakeholders, including experts and officials, expressed concerns about RNG’s availability, affordability, and overall effectiveness in addressing the state’s emission targets. According to data, a 2019 study found that only 17% of Rhode Island households could potentially be served by RNG by the year 2050.

The state’s Public Utilities Commission (PUC) formed the stakeholder committee as part of its “Future of Gas” initiative. This initiative was initiated in response to the Act on Climate legislation, which mandates a significant reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030, 2040, and achieving net-zero emissions by 2050. The PUC is tasked with developing a strategy to transition customers off natural gas without compromising funding and consumer protections.

As the committee continues its deliberations, regulators aim to incorporate its findings into the broader strategy for the gas distribution system transition. Observations from neighboring Massachusetts indicate the complexities of a similar initiative, as they opted not to rely heavily on RNG due to availability and cost concerns. This rejection was largely informed by research that highlighted similar challenges related to RNG in addressing emissions reduction goals.

Alternative recommendations put forth by stakeholders focus on enhancing electrification, improving energy efficiency, discouraging further expansion of the gas system, and strategically decommissioning existing gas infrastructure. Experts maintain that without comprehensive funding mechanisms in place, transitioning from fossil fuels to cleaner energy sources may be difficult. Vermont and Massachusetts are exploring clean heat standards, while New York is investigating cap-and-invest strategies to facilitate this transition.

Importantly, the transition to electrification raises questions about affordability, especially for low-income households that may face increased costs as the state shifts away from natural gas. Stakeholders have pointed out the necessity of establishing protective measures to support these customers. Proposed solutions have included capping electricity expenses in relation to income, implementing rate reforms, and providing assistance for electric heat pump installations.

The committee is expected to finalize its report and deliver recommendations to the PUC by the end of the year. As Rhode Island navigates these transformative changes, the focus remains on balancing environmental objectives with economic implications for all residents.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

• Providence Journal: High Electric Bill in Rhode Island
• Rhode Island Current: State Utility Regulators Slash RI Energy’s Budget
• Canary Media: Rhode Island Considers Future of Gas
• Valley Breeze: RI Energy Confirms Winter Rates Won’t Change
• Wikipedia: Rhode Island